South African Court Blocks Coal Expansion in Key Energy Ruling
South Africa’s Supreme Court of Appeal dismissed the government’s appeal against a High Court ruling that struck down 1,500 megawatts of planned coal-fired power plant capacity. The High Court had previously found this expansion violates constitutional rights to a healthy environment and grid stability, with the government’s technical arguments deemed insufficient. The Centre for Environmental Rights represented plaintiffs in the case, noting coal plants cause annual air pollution deaths exceeding 2,200 South Africans and thousands of asthma and bronchitis cases. Michelle Sithole, senior associate at the Centre, emphasized the government must justify coal use with cheaper, cleaner alternatives. The ruling creates immediate friction for South Africa’s energy transition, as the government retains the option to appeal to the Constitutional Court. This legal win prevents a major expansion of coal capacity that would worsen air pollution and energy instability. For communities reliant on coal for electricity, it reduces near-term risks of health deterioration and grid failures. The next critical step is whether the government appeals to the Constitutional Court, which could delay or reverse the environmental protections. The source explicitly states the government retains this appeal path.
Source: Mongabay
Many Minded