Many Minded · The cost curves · CONNECTION

How much does people still offline cost?

people still offline (% of people) · % of people · measured 2005–2025 · fitted live from 21 observations by the Many Minded cost-curve engine.

The last measured value is 26.4% (2025, ITU ICT Indicators (via World Bank / OWID)). Over the fitted window the series falls 7.9% a year (80% interval −9.0% to −6.8%) — a halving every 8.4 years (80%: 7.4–9.9). Carried forward on that fit, 2030: 17.5% (80%: 15.8%–19.4%).

26.4%latest measured (2025)−7.9%fitted, per year8.4yper halving21observations, 2005–2025measuredbasis

the curve

people still offline — measured history and fitted projectionpeople still offline: measured 2005–2025 in % of people, last value 26.4%, fitted at −7.9% a year, projected to 2033 inside an 80% interval, against a gate at 5.0%. Logarithmic vertical axis.% of people1010020052009201320172021202520292033gate 5.0%26.4% (2025)
Vertical axis: % of people, log scale. Solid: measured observations. Dashed: the fitted central projection. Shaded: the 80% interval, which widens with horizon because shocks accumulate. Red dashed: the gate at 5.0%.

what this series measures

share of the WORLD population NOT using the internet (100 − ITU individuals-using-the-internet, world aggregate) — not coverage, not subscriptions.

the gate — what crossing this threshold changes

universal internet use (ITU’s ≥95% bar)
threshold ≤ 5% of people offline · fires: free information and free intelligence in every hand

Central fit: ~2045. 80% window: 2043–2050 · n=11. That is 2.4 halvings away at today's value.

●●○○day 2 of 4 in the pond · 2.4 halvings to the gate. One "day" per halving: the pond fills on the last one, and is only half covered the day before.

what the fit says

quantityvaluehow it is computed
fitted rate−7.9%/yr (80%: −9.0% to −6.8%)Farmer–Lafond drift over the trailing window · n=11 points, 10 years
halving time8.4 years (80%: 7.4–9.9)implied by the fitted drift
curve checkaccelerating (−3% → −8%/yr)first half of the record versus the second, judged against the direction that helps this metric (falling)
regime break~2017 (−4% → −9%/yr, F=206)Chow-style best single breakpoint, kept only above a conservative sup-F threshold

Not shown for this curve, because the machinery returns nothing: Wright's law (no cumulative-deployment series for this technology).

the projection, with its interval

Log cost as a random walk with drift: the forecast variance grows with horizon (τ + τ²/m), which is why these bands widen instead of staying parallel. The middle column is the least useful number on this page; the interval is the claim.

yearcentral fit80% interval
202624.3%23.4% to 25.3%near horizon
202722.4%21.1% to 23.7%near horizon
202820.6%19.1% to 22.2%near horizon
202919.0%17.4% to 20.8%the band is already wide here
203017.5%15.8% to 19.4%the band is already wide here
203116.1%14.3% to 18.1%the band is already wide here
203214.8%13.0% to 16.9%far horizon — read the interval, not the middle
203313.7%11.8% to 15.8%far horizon — read the interval, not the middle

Projected to 2033, the horizon the whole engine uses.

questions this page answers

How much does people still offline cost?

26.4% as of 2025, the latest measured value in the series (ITU ICT Indicators (via World Bank / OWID)). The fitted trend has it falling 7.9% a year, with an 80% interval of −9.0% to −6.8%.

How fast is people still offline falling?

−7.9% a year over the fitted window, an 80% interval of −9.0% to −6.8% — a halving every 8.4 years (80%: 7.4 to 9.9 years). Fitted from 11 observations spanning 10 years.

What will people still offline be in 2030?

The central fit says 17.5%, inside an 80% interval of 15.8% to 19.4%. The interval is the forecast; the middle number is only its midpoint. Bands widen with horizon because shocks accumulate — a constant-width band would be overconfident.

When will people still offline reach ≤ 5% of people offline?

The central fit says ~2045, with an 80% window of 2043–2050 from 11 observations. Crossing it is what the engine calls "universal internet use (ITU’s ≥95% bar)", firing: free information and free intelligence in every hand. Treat the window, not the year, as the claim.

Is the decline in people still offline accelerating or slowing?

Splitting the record in half, the fitted rate went from −3% to −8% a year — accelerating. A Chow-style test finds a regime break around 2017 (−4% → −9% a year, F=206). Regime breaks, not window choice, are what dominate this method's errors — which is why every projection here carries an interval.

Where does this data come from?

ITU ICT Indicators (via World Bank / OWID). 21 observations spanning 2005–2025. Curated benchmark history, extended by a weekly authoritative fetch and by news figures fact-checked against their source before they may touch a fit. Both the observation ledger and the fitting code are public, and the engine publishes its own calibration score and its misses.

the raw numbers

Every observation behind the fit, unrounded by us and unsmoothed. This table is here on purpose: graphs make people underestimate exponential change, and the raw series beside the curve is the one correction shown to work.

year% of peoplechange
200584.4%—
200682.8%−1.9%
200779.8%−3.6%
200877.2%−3.3%
200974.7%−3.2%
201071.6%−4.1%
201169.1%−3.5%
201266.7%−3.5%
201364.7%−3.0%
201462.6%−3.2%
201560.1%−4.0%
201656.4%−6.2%
201753.7%−4.8%
201850.6%−5.8%
201946.1%−8.9%
202039.9%−13.4%
202136.2%−9.3%
202233.0%−8.8%
202330.8%−6.7%
202428.8%−6.5%
202526.4%−8.3%

where this comes from

Other CONNECTION curves:

Recent briefs from CONNECTION, the daily record of what moved:

every CONNECTION brief →

Every tracked curve: utility solar, installed · battery pack price · battery cell price · solar module price · disk storage · human genome sequencing · transistors per chip · fastest supercomputer · DRAM memory · solid-state storage · onshore wind electricity · solar electricity (LCOE) · space launch, to LEO · wheat yield · offshore wind electricity · AI task horizon (METR) · frontier AI training compute · modular housing, turnkey · frontier-grade intelligence · AI video, finished minute · humanoid robot, capable unit · cheapest humanoid, list price · farm labor share · healthcare spend per person

← the whole engine: build clock, cascade, calibration · the archive · how we know